The impact of self and peer-grading on student learning

Ananda Verheijen
Rebecca LeBoeuf
Rebecca LeBoeuf
|
July 4, 2016
Table of Contents
Join Rotterdam School of Management to explore the best practices for implementing CBE and discover the new FeedbackFruits Competency-Based Assessment solution.
REGISTER NOW
A common teaching practice is to give students detailed feedback about the strengths and weaknesses of their work, with suggestions for improvement.


However, besides the fact that providing teacher feedback is often a time-consuming job (Wind & Jensen, 2017), the impact of teacher feedback is sometimes regarded as poor (Sadler, 2010). For example, if students would only receive feedback after they have submitted their final work, they might not effectively process this feedback, despite the investment of considerable time and effort put into its construction by the teacher.

Needless to say, relevant and helpful feedback on work is important to ensure a good learning experience for students. But instead of receiving it only from a teacher, relevant feedback could also be provided by peers as a combined solution to the above challenges (low impact of teacher feedback and considerable time/effort made by teacher). Hence over the years, peer assessment as a learning method has become more and more popular among teachers (Wind & Jensen, 2017).

But how about self-assessment and peer review?

In the Peer Review tool built by FeedbackFruits, it is possible to add self-assessment to assignments where students provide each other with feedback.

Early research of Sadler (2006) has illustrated that by adding self-grading / evaluation to peer assessment, one can achieve increased student learning. Asking students to not only reflect on received peer feedback but to also review their own contributions increases the interest and motivation level of students. It also aids in the development of critical skills. However, it should be noted that in the study of Sadler (2006) ideal conditions for student self-assessment existed. Specifically, the students in this study were well trained (in grading themselves and others) by the teacher and had access to a rubric provided by the teacher that codified their own and the teacher’s judgment.

Hence, providing students with the right learning materials and instructions is key in this case. In order to digitally support these ideal conditions, FeedbackFruits has focussed on building rubric functionality (mentioned in the previous blog) and extensive instruction possibilities. The teacher instructions are provided as a first step in the student flow, well before students will actually review (step 1 in the tool). Additionally, students are reminded of the instructions and how to provide constructive feedback during the actual process of reviewing with real-time feedback tips (EUR project currently in beta). Finally, once the activity is completed, FeedbackFruits provides analytics to both student and teacher on the ratio of given self-assessments to received peer assessments. This metric makes it easier to compare a student’s own evaluation to those made by others. Concluding, by featuring the concept of self-grading in this newsletter we have highlighted both the pedagogical value as the practical value as a time saver.

Share on social media

More from FeedbackFruits tips series

Technology Tips
|
23/3/2023

5 ways to stimulate collaboration with FeedbackFruits Team Based Learning

5 ways optimize the team-based learning process with the support of technology

Technology Tips
|
28/10/2022

Develop critical thinking with Discussion on Work | FeedbackFruits tips

Check out 4 ways to design asynchronous discussions that stimulate critical thinking skills

Technology Tips
|
28/10/2022

Stimulate continuous engagement with Interactive Document | FeedbackFruits tips

Discover how to maintain continuous student engagement at every stage of your course using Interactive Document

Most popular blog posts

Student Success
|
Nov 16, 2023

Promote active learning in different instructional modes

Explore how to best implement active learning strategies with deep understanding of different modalities

Industry News
|
Sep 11, 2023

Meet the new FeedbackFruits partners | Summer 2023 Highlights

FeedbackFruits announces partnerships with many institutions worldwide over the past 4 months

Student Success
|
Aug 23, 2023

Competency-based education (CBE) in higher education: A landscape overview

An overview of the state of competency-based education (CBE) in higher education around the world

Subscribe for educational articles, practical pedagogical tips & tricks, event updates, invites and more. Unsubscribe anytime.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Filling out this form means you agree to our Privacy Policy.