icon
Learning activity

Practicing using AI to build strong essay arguments

Template to develop essay arguments with AI Practice and enhance skills through peer feedback on prompts
Created by:
Pedagogy
Learning outcome
Prep time
Intermediate (10-30 min)
Activity type
Learning Activity
Hero image

Why this learning activity?

Learning activities targeting high-order skills like this one can help you activate students more effectively. This learning activity will help you with:
Icon

Enhance prompt design and AI interaction skills

Students will create effective prompts for AI to extract meaningful insights from a text, learning to guide AI tools to support critical thinking and research processes.
Button Text
Icon

Develop critical argumentation skills

Students will use AI to generate, analyze, and evaluate arguments for and against a given topic, strengthening their ability to construct balanced and evidence-based positions.
Button Text
Icon

Apply peer feedback to improve learning

Students will review and reflect on feedback received from peers on their AI chat summaries, identifying ways to refine their prompts, analysis, and overall approach to developing arguments.
Button Text

Activity setup

Practicing using AI to build strong essay arguments

Start using this template

Activity steps

  1. Read instructions: Students carefully review the activity instructions and learning outcomes.
  2. Read article: Students read the article attached to the instructions.
  3. AI practice: Students upload the article to the AI Practice chat and create several prompts to analyze the arguments for and against the topic.
  4. Peer review: Students submit a summary of their AI chat and complete a peer review by providing feedback on their peers’ use of prompts.
  5. Reflection: Students review the feedback they received and write a reflection on what they learned from the exercise.
  6. Grading: Grades are assigned based on completion of the activity.

Activity goals

This activity helps facilitate a flipped classroom approach to your teaching. When student engage with material prior to class there are several benefits:
  1. Read instructions: Students carefully review the activity instructions and learning outcomes.
  2. Read article: Students read the article attached to the instructions.
  3. AI practice: Students upload the article to the AI Practice chat and create several prompts to analyze the arguments for and against the topic.
  4. Peer review: Students submit a summary of their AI chat and complete a peer review by providing feedback on their peers’ use of prompts.
  5. Reflection: Students review the feedback they received and write a reflection on what they learned from the exercise.
  6. Grading: Grades are assigned based on completion of the activity.

Learning Activities Used

Peer Review

Stimulate lifelong learning with peer feedback

In this activity

  • An article exploring the pros and cons of smartphones in schools is provided as a sample text. This can be replaced with a topic more relevant to your course.
  • Students are encouraged to submit 3–6 messages to the AI Practice chat to develop their prompts and responses. This number can be adjusted based on your activity goals.
  • Prompt suggestions are turned off in this activity, as students are already guided through how to structure and refine their prompts. However, you can enable prompt suggestions if you would like to provide additional scaffolding or examples for students learning to use AI.
  • Peer review is integrated, allowing students to evaluate each other’s AI prompts and provide constructive feedback, reinforcing critical thinking and collaborative learning.
  • A structured rubric is included to guide students in giving clear, concise, and constructive feedback to their peers. You can modify or expand the rubric to suit your needs.
  • A reflection step is included to prompt students to consider what they learned from the exercise and how it can inform their future practice.

Notable settings

Anonymity
Reflection
Grading

Download this template as PDF

Not a FeedbackFruits user? Don't worry, you can download this template in PDF by filling out the form below
Close

Get this template in your LMS

FeedbackFruits users can directly copy this template in their LMS and start using it in their courses
Click on the region you are located in:
Close