[Live webinar] Unlock the power of group work with peer-to-peer learning

5 essential tips to digitalize authentic assessment [Updated 2022]

Nhi Nguyen
Rebecca LeBoeuf
Rebecca LeBoeuf
April 1, 2021
Table of Contents

We all agree that assessment should go beyond a numerical grade: it needs to provide an objective, holistic, qualitative reflection of students' performance and progress. In other words, “assessment practices should assess students holistically, including knowledge, abilities, values, attitudes and habits of mind that affect academic success and performance beyond the classroom” [1]. Educators are then presented with the challenge of finding the most suitable approach that embraces this demand. This is where authentic assessment comes in, with the focus on measuring students' success in skill-relevant and real-life situations.

The concept of authentic assessment is not new, in fact it has been adopted since the early 20s, mostly within the face-to-face classroom. As online education becomes the new normal, it is even more important to implement this assessment practice to create an engaging and fruitful learning experience. Considering the distinction between direct and remote classroom, the implementation of authentic assessment is necessarily different. Online courses remove geographical and physical barriers, allow for constant access to course materials, and offer endless potential of pedagogical technology. Therefore, educators should make use of these advantages to create authentic, engaging assessment.

In this article, you will find effective, classroom-proof tips on how to initiate authentic assessment in digital classrooms, by utilizing teaching and learning tools.

A selection of use cases and rubric templates for self, peer, and group assessment, which have been designed and successfully adopted by institutions worldwide.
Join Cole Groom of FeedbackFruits and Patricia Luna of TAMU for an in-depth webinar exploring authentic assessment and how it can transform your approach to student evaluations

What is authentic assessment?

In the paper – Defining and measuring authentic assessment: a case study in the context of tertiary science, Tiffany Gunning, Madeleine Schultz, Karen Young, and Michelle Harvey of Deakin University proposed a concrete definition of authentic assessment:

“Authentic assessment requires students to engage with a problem or task that is contextualized within a realistic environment and assesses the knowledge skills and attitudes required in  the workplace community and for lifelong learning.”

Based on this definition, the team developed a 6-step tool that helps faculties assess the authenticity level of the task. A summary of the steps can be found in figure 1.

Summary of Authentic Assessment tool (Schultz, Young, Gunning, & Harvey, 2021)
Figure 1. Summary of Authentic Assessment tool (Schultz, Young, Gunning, & Harvey, 2021)

5 pillars of authentic assessment

For an assessment to be considered authentic, it needs to:

     1. Be based on realistic, real-life situations
     2. Deliver clear objectives and goals
     3. Allow for collaboration and teamwork
     4. Take the form of formative assessment
     5. Encourage feedback and reflection

Within the online setting where all the interactions happen behind the screen, it takes teachers extra effort to make sure the assessment covers all these elements. We will hereby elaborate on each of the above features and explain how instructors can optimize them in remote courses.

1 | Be realistic, performance-based and cognitively complex

Since authentic assessment measures how students apply the attained knowledge and skills in real world situations, teachers need to design an assessment activity that replicates authentic, real-world scenarios. This seems to be a challenge in online settings due to physical constraints. In fact, technology has all the capacity to help generate authentic contexts that “promote real world problem solving in all disciplines” [1]. With different remote platforms or softwares, teachers can create virtual simulations of a virtual lab activity, debate session, or panel discussion where students can interact and collaborate with each other just like in face-to-face situations. For example, NHL Stenden University of Applied Sciences implemented a design-based-education project in which students worked together to create a media product for a client. The entire activity was facilitated entirely online, with support from FeedbackFruits tools: Interactive Study Materials, Peer Review, and Group Member Evaluation. Both instructors and students acknowledged the vital role of learning tools in promoting feedback and collaborative skills, as well as saving time in running the activity.

2 | Deliver a clear set of objectives  

Developing an authentic assessment should always begin with setting clear goals and objectives. This is to make sure students understand what is expected of them upon completing the assignment. Learning objectives “serve as the roadmap to course content”, highlighting the workplace-relevant knowledge and skills that students will be able to gain after the course [2, p. 65]. Therefore, teachers need to define clear goals for the course and make sure learners are fully aware of these learning outcomes. The real challenge; however, doesn't lie in crafting SMART goals, but in making sure learners are aware of these goals and follow them. In fact, teachers often complain how difficult and time-consuming it is to have to constantly remind students of the course objectives. This is where educational technology comes in and helps relieve such burdens. At FeedbackFruits, we built learning tools that allow instructors to develop learning goals using electronic templates, set automatic reminders of deadlines and course goals, and establish students' progress tracking.

3 | Allow for collaboration and teamwork 

Another crucial feature of authentic assessment is its collaborative nature. Since education focuses more on preparing learners for future employment, developing teamwork and collaboration skills is a must. Considering the online transition, the ability to effectively work together is no longer confined to the face-to-face setting, but is extended to the remote environment. Therefore, we can't ignore the value of technology-enhanced collaborative assessment. With an array of technological tools available, educators are presented with endless opportunities to facilitate authentic assessment. Innovative and effective practices that encourage collaboration include online discussion, individual or group projects, e-portfolios, poster design, simulations, and online quizzes. Using different learning technologies, educators can easily create and facilitate these assessments. To understand how you can do this, check out our ebook in which we elaborate on the features and implementation of each of the methods in the digital classroom. 

4 | Take the form of formative and ongoing assessment 

Constant and ongoing assessment provides timely feedback on student performance, thus helping teachers to adjust the course content and offer timely support for their learners [4]. The best approach to generate continuous evaluation is to effectively integrate both formative and summative assessment forms. A variety of strategies can be adopted by teachers to exercise this approach, namely: assign grades for students' peer comments, in-class quizzes; implement peer feedback throughout the assignment; organise review sessions before and after the final exam. Within online settings, educational technology allows teachers to quickly and conveniently design these assessment activities. We have written a detailed article explaining how you can utilise educational technology to combine both formative and summative assessment.

5 | Encourage feedback and reflection 

Authentic assessment calls for authentic feedback. Consistent, timely, specific, and constructive feedback not only supports the teaching experience, but also provides students with multiple opportunities to reflect on and adjust their work according to the required standard [2] [5]. This is highly authentic and similar to the workplace context. 

In online settings, educators can digitalise feedback using pedagogical technology. Several tools and platforms allow teachers to facilitate an effective, sustainable feedback culture, in which feedback happens frequently and in varied forms. FeedbackFruits provides the perfect example of technology-integrated solutions, as we build feedback tools that cater to different aspects of feedback activities: allowing students to filter their assessment, assigning peer reviewers, configurable grading, setting up explanation cards, implementing self-assessment or group evaluation.

We'd recommend you to read our ebook – "Feedback for learning: A comprehensive guide", which provides further insights into how to facilitate effective feedback in different course settings.

How to create Authentic Assessment: Authentic Assessment across a STEM Faculty at Deakin University

Dr. Tiffany Gunning, senior lecturer and her team at the Faculty of Science, Engineering and Built Environment of Deakin University have been implementing a 2-year long, multi-faceted project to prepare students for the world of work and encourage lifelong learning.

This project, running from 2021 to 2023, involves scaffolding authentic assessment tasks across 3 touch points (steps) in every undergraduate course offered by the faculty. Check this use case to learn more about how Dr. Gunning and her team successfully implemented this project and their plan for scaling this approach to more subjects and courses.


The transition to online education has highlighted the role of authentic assessment strategies in increasing learner engagement and helping students to develop higher-order cognitive skills that align with expectations of the 21st century work life. Educators can absolutely achieve this assessment goal with an innovative mindset and the aid of learning technology. Educational technology offers endless tools for teachers to put pedagogical creativity into practice and deliver effective, authentic assessment practices. 

For further ideas and resources on how to craft authentic, engaging assessment strategies for your students, check out our latest ebook – "Quality teaching and learning: Achieving the higher education we deserve".

Share on social media

More from FeedbackFruits tips series

Technology Tips

5 ways to stimulate collaboration with FeedbackFruits Team Based Learning

5 ways optimize the team-based learning process with the support of technology

Technology Tips

Develop critical thinking with Discussion on Work | FeedbackFruits tips

Check out 4 ways to design asynchronous discussions that stimulate critical thinking skills

Technology Tips

Stimulate continuous engagement with Interactive Document | FeedbackFruits tips

Discover how to maintain continuous student engagement at every stage of your course using Interactive Document

Most popular blog posts

Student Success
Nov 16, 2023

Promote active learning in different instructional modes

Explore how to best implement active learning strategies with deep understanding of different modalities

Industry News
Sep 11, 2023

Meet the new FeedbackFruits partners | Summer 2023 Highlights

FeedbackFruits announces partnerships with many institutions worldwide over the past 4 months

Student Success
Aug 23, 2023

Competency-based education (CBE) in higher education: A landscape overview

An overview of the state of competency-based education (CBE) in higher education around the world

We gather the most valuable resources and learnings on pedagogy and email them to you. Once a month. Unsubscribe whenever you want.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Filling out this form means you agree to our Privacy Policy.